It’s fine to steal for a union, but not from a union

It’s fine to steal for a union, but not from a union

Delaware’s AFSCME 3911 got a dose of payback this week and apparently concluded the same tactics unions have used against their members for years can’t just be shrugged off when the roles are reversed.

As reported by Philadelphia’s Station 6 ABC News, a Delaware man is accused of stealing more $126,000 from his own union by forging signatures of members onto phony checks over the course of three years.

Wilmington resident Matthew Adams, a former employee and board member of AFSCME Local 3911, was arrested by U.S. marshals in the Virgin Islands and is currently awaiting extradition on charges of fraud and theft.

Really? You mean those things are crimes?

As you may remember, the Freedom Foundation has uncovered dozens of cases Oregon and California in which public employee unions including AFSCME and SEIU were caught red-handed forging their members’ signatures on dues-deduction forms in order to continue siphoning off a portion of their paycheck even after the worker had made it clear he or she wanted to exercise their Constitutional right to opt out.

This past June, in fact, Freedom Foundation attorneys appealed a forgery-related case from Washington to the U.S. Supreme Court

As is their practice, the justices declined to consider the case because it would have required them to reinforce their 2018 ruling in Janus v. AFSCME, which addressed just this sort of union criminality.

Instead, the court let stand a lower court ruling later affirmed by the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals holding that, because the state had delegated its payroll responsibilities to the union, it couldn’t be held responsible for deducting dues from a worker based on a bogus membership form. And because the union wasn’t a state actor — meaning it lacked the authority it had been permitted to exercise — it, too, was blameless.

It bears noting that in none of the cases litigated by the Freedom Foundation did law enforcement even treat the forgery as a crime. No serious criminal investigation was ever undertaken, nor were the perpetrators ever prosecuted.

Evidently the double standard extends from coast to coast and even beyond U.S. shores. It’s perfectly fine for unions to forge membership applications for workers who wouldn’t otherwise sign up so their wages can be stolen and funneled into the pockets of union leaders.

But when a union officer uses the same tactic on the union itself, suddenly fraud and theft become a federal case.

East Coast Director
Hunter Tower was hired as the Pennsylvania Director for the Freedom Foundation in March 2020 and now serves as the East Coast Director. Hunter has previously served as Executive Director of the Republican Committee of Lancaster County and as a Field Director with the PAGOP. He has also served as a Campaign Manager for a State Representative race in Connecticut and has lobbied Congress on behalf of his Fraternity (Theta Chi) and the Fraternal Government Relations Coalition (FGRC) to pass the Collegiate Housing and Infrastructure Act (CHIA). Hunter has been featured in many outlets across the East Coast and the nation such as RealClearPolicy, RedState, Center Square, Broad + Liberty, Penn Live, City & State, and Lincoln Radio Journal. He’s a member and Parliamentarian of the Pennsylvania Advisory Committee to the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights. He has facilitated several national and regional events for his Fraternity, is a charter member of his local Rotary Club, a Kentucky Colonel, and a former member of Kennett Township (PA) Zoning Hearing Board. Hunter’s family has a long history in politics beginning with Charlemagne Tower Jr., who served as Minister to Austria-Hungary (1897–1899) for President William McKinley before being transferred to Russia as Ambassador (1899–1902). Following his post in St. Petersburg, Charlemagne served as Ambassador to Germany from 1902 to 1908 under President Theodore Roosevelt. Tower City in Schuylkill County, Pennsylvania is named after his father, Charlemagne Tower, as is Tower, Minnesota, and Tower City, North Dakota. Hunter’s cousin, former United States Senator John G. Tower (R-Texas), served 24 years in the Senate and was George H.W. Bush’s first nominee for Secretary of Defense. Hunter’s late father, John W. Tower, was President Richard Nixon’s aide at the 1972 RNC in Florida with Alexander Haig’s son, worked with the Reagan Administration in the 1980s, and was a lobbyist in Washington, DC as President of American Strategy Group. Hunter is a graduate of Widener University in Chester, PA with a B.A. in Political Science. Hunter and his wife reside in Pennsylvania, with their two children and two rescue dogs.